Challenging the decision of a lower court is a complex process. It begins with an examination of the record, which is followed by issue identification, research, brief writing and, ultimately, oral argument before the Court.
We are familiar with the specialized procedures involved with the appellate process in Connecticut. Our attorneys have decades of combined experience handling appeals in both civil (including habeas) and criminal (direct) appellate cases.
The Connecticut Criminal Appeals Process
Following the imposition of a sentence, a criminal defendant has the right to appeal their conviction within a short time period. Let’s discuss the steps taken during the Connecticut appeal process:
Step 1: Filing the Notice of Appeal
The process commences with the filing of a Notice of Appeal. This formal document signals your intent to challenge the decision rendered in your original civil or criminal trial (or plea — guilty pleas are appealable, albeit in a more limited way). Timing is critical, as strict deadlines must be adhered to, making it essential to act swiftly with the guidance of a qualified attorney.
Step 2: Legal Briefs and Arguments
Once the appeal is initiated, the heart of the appellate process lies in the preparation and presentation of legal briefs and arguments. This is where the intricate dance of legal reasoning and persuasion takes center stage. Your legal team, which ideally includes an experienced appellate attorney, will craft a compelling appellate brief reciting the facts and standards, as well as outlining the legal errors. Only legal errors may be challenged in an appeal. An appeal is not the proper forum to produce new factual evidence or argue ineffective assistance of counsel. The Connecticut Appellate Court will only examine the record made in the proceedings of a lower court and any properly preserved claims.
Step 3: Oral Arguments
The oral argument is the opportunity to answer the Court’s questions. The judges have read the brief and its appendix and have reviewed relevant portions of the transcripts before taking the bench. This is their opportunity to ask questions and challenge the claims and defenses made. Your attorney will stand before the appellate judges or justices, passionately advocating for your claims, meticulously dissecting the flaws in the trial court’s proceedings, and offering compelling reasons why your verdict, conviction or sentence should be overturned.
Step 4: The Decision
The judges or justices, after thorough review and deliberation, may take one of two paths for an appeal:
- Affirm: Your verdict, conviction or sentence is affirmed, meaning it is upheld and your appeal is denied.
- Reverse & Remand: The appellate court finds merit in your arguments, overturning your conviction or sentence, ordering particular relief, or a new trial. The case may be sent back to the lower court for further proceedings or corrections.
Step 5: Further Appeals and Habeas Corpus
If the appellate court’s decision is unfavorable, you may still have options. Additional appeals, called petitions for certification to appeal, may be filed in higher courts, under certain circumstances and within certain time periods.
If your underlying case was criminal, you may also wish to explore other post-conviction remedies, such as habeas corpus petitions, sentence modification, motion to correct illegal sentence, sentence review, commutation, writs of error, etc., which allow for a review of the legality of your detention based on various factors such as ineffective assistance of counsel or newly discovered evidence.
Testimonials
Read what our clients have to say in their own words.
Other Considerations: Appellate Bonds
In Connecticut, an appellate bond is a type of bond required in criminal cases when a defendant is appealing a decision made by a lower court and wishes to remain free from incarceration during the appeals process.
This bond is designed to ensure that the appellant (the party filing the appeal) will report to serve their sentence if the lower court’s decision is upheld and the appeal is unsuccessful.
If you are seeking an appellate bond, contact our office.
Why Choose Our Firm for Your Criminal Appeal?
Our team will meticulously review your case and examine the details, exploring the available claims, sometimes even arguing to make new law. We understand Connecticut’s criminal laws, appellate procedures, and the complex intricacies of the appeals process. Our legal team listens to our clients’ thoughts on what went wrong and keeps our clients informed as we identify the most promising claims. We are passionate about the relentless, zealous advocacy needed to achieve a favorable outcome. Get in touch with our Connecticut Criminal Appeals Attorneys today
Inquiries
Contact Brodeur Law Firm, LLC
Fill out the inquiry form by clicking the button below.

